Here Today... Gone To Hell!

what if this album finally gets released and it sucks.....It is a possibility.....Will that change the publics yearning for axl and the new GNR.....or will it be a death bell for the once mighty mr. rose........As for me I will never stop loving the stuff AXL did from 1985-1993 and if the new album blows I will still support the man but it is a big question..Will GNR turn into Metallica- a once mighty behomoth that is now old and washed up and still living on past success or will they be more like the Chili Peppers- a band 20 years into their career and still churning out some of the best music they have ever done.......Admit it or not it is a major question mark and also a question as to how die hard GNR fans liek me will react......If this album blows it will further wet people'sa ppetite for an old reunion

not possible that it sucks.

It IS possible that it will NOT live up to expectations, which have been built up more than any other album in history, but sucks?  Not possible.

I think they'll take the Peppers route. come on, if the songs we've heard (except Silkworms) are on the album, it's already great! : ok:

then go buy the new VR disk :hihi:

the higher the expectations the more it will disappoint...no such thing as a perfect album IMO :peace:

don't think I won't! ;D

It might well suck. If it was any good it would have been released years ago.

IF it were to suck....it'd suck.? This is music, after all, and not some serious global issue that our lives depend on.? It's $15 out of my pocket and a couple hours out of my life spent listening to it.? Not, really, a big deal.? It would, I think, pretty much kill the current incarnation of the band....but I guess if it sucks, that's whats meant to be, eh?

But honestly, given the material we've heard.....Maddy, the Blues, IRS, Better, TWAT, CITR, CD...assuming MOST of that makes it on the album...I'd be hard pressed to say it sucks.? Hell, those 7 tracks, alone, with 6 tracks of "filler" would make it a worthwhile purchase, IMHO, and about on par with, if not slightly better than, many other albums released today.

hey I'm gonna too, VR fucking rocks!! ?;)

....tons of new great new music this year and next (and last year too i suppose) its a fantastic time to be a music fan : ok: I'm sure CD won't disappoint many of us :smoking:

If CD sucks?

I'm sorry, that doesn't compute. ???







 ;D

If it has most of the songs we have already heard its already a great album  : ok:

What if Axl replaced Maddy,Blues,or Better by a song like Silkworms?Well,its Sucks.
but I still buy the album, anyway :hihi:.

Go listen to the leaks.

shit if CD has, songs like TWAT, Better, IRS, The Blues, Madagascar, CD, plus 7 other songs say 4 are rockers and 3 are slower.  It wont suck, but if he decides to put Silkworms on it not put any of the songs above on it, and introduce Riyad as the first single, then it will suck.  It would also make no sense to do that either.  So I dont think it will, the music will be awesome.  Know if people go buy CD thinking they're buying the next AFD, then they will definetly think it sucks, But people who do that suck for not knowing the difference

If it sucks, I'll throw my cheerios at my stereo and yell NOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOO! like Darth Vader.

one of the worstests topic ever

I like couple of new songs,so albumdefinitely won't sucks

no matter what it'll live up to my expectations, GN'R records are event records.
just the history behind it makes it interesting enough for me.
michael jacksons 'invincible' album sold rubbish and had bad reviews but it's probably on par with 'thriller'

what i'm saying is i can't really see it sucking, even if it did he said he's gonna release three albums in a short period of time. ?:peace:

It's not going to suck... lol. :peace:

Then everyone on HTGTH will still think Axl was GNR , Slash is a fraud and Robin Finck is the best guitarist to grace God's green earth.


Truthfully, the only way it sucks is if Axl OVERPRODUCED it, Chris Pittman is on it, and Axl sounds like 2002 Axl. If he sounds like he does the majority of the time now (2002 Axl creeps up every now and then) and Chris Pittman is muted, it will be fucking sex.

Uhhh... It was definately NOT on par with Thriller...

On the GNR record; the strongest argument is probably the leaks so far. TWAT, The Blues, Madagascar, Chinese Democracy, Better, ... Those songs alone make a good to great album.

what if.....shut the shit up!!!!! 8)

If it sucks, it sucks.

If it rocks, it rocks... : ok:

Better, TWAT and IRS already make the CD good... so It can't suck :D + there's The Blues, CD, Maddy, and CITR... if the new gnr can make all these songs that rock so much, there is not a chance that it will suck

What if it sucks? Hm.. is that a possibility? I suppose. :-\

But I highly doubt it, all the "leaks" that i've heard have been really great IMO, I can't stop listening to T.W.A.T or Better :peace:

The fact that the album has been delayed and delayed and delayed and.. you get it.. probably will hurt the CD when it eventually comes out, whenever that may be. There is so much anticipation for it that it might be hurt by the long wait as fans may expect too much.. if that makes any sense. I think Chinese Democracy will be an awesome CD and I don't think many people will be let down, except for the people who like to constantly bash GnR no matter how good they are, hopefully it comes out this fall and they start a tour here in North America  : ok:

Not gonna happen.  The leaks, The Blues, Maddy, etc. are all well worth it.  The worst case scenario is that the few songs we haven't heard yet will be lackluster, and I don't think that's very likely...

The leaks of the songs we have heard so far...

Catcher In The Rye
T.W.A.T
IRS
Madagascar
Chinese Democracy
The Blues
Better

Thats 7 songs, half of a CD in most cases.. and IMO all those songs are exceptional, and some might not even make the cut. If they can make 7 quality songs, like those mentioned above, just imagine what this CD is going to sound like!!
:beer:

I think CITR will be on the next disk...no particular reason except that they seem to be pretending that it didn't leak :-\