Here Today... Gone To Hell!

This guy on MyGNRForum is a particularly unpleasant character. He claims to have 15 seconds of a song we've "never heard of." I asked for a sample and he asked for my phone number. Why would someone who has a sample of a song - which he claimed he was willing to pass around to prove he had other songs - need a telephone number? I could easily just record whatever he plays me through the phone. The answer is that he can say he was banned from MyGNR and lost my number, and keep putting off calling me.

I do believe he has Catcher in the Rye. I don't believe he has anything else. And I believe he's attempting to make other fans jealous.

Don't believe everyone who comes on here claiming to have all these songs, because I've run into a lot of liars so far who don't have anything. I'm not trying to sound like an "expert" - but I've seen people offer money and I think it's ridiculous. Have patience. Whatever is out there will leak eventually. (I really thought Catcher would be out by the end of the weekend.)

I think some other songs ARE out there - but people holding off on releasing CITR are stupid because people who have the REALLY rare songs already have the "less" rare songs like CITR. And I don't think trading something ultra-obscure like Prostitute for a song many people have (Catcher) is a fair bargain, do you?

This is going to keep going in circles and people are going to keep lying until someone, somewhere, finally obtains a copy of the song through someone else and leaks it.

Just a thought.

By the way - if you DO have Catcher in the Rye, and you are reading this, and think you can hold on to it to trade for another song...trust me, it ain't gonna happen. Everyone looking to trade already has it. And people who MIGHT have other songs have CITR already. You're just delaying the inevitable.

I made sure to log that down in a journal. I appreciate your thoughts.

so who decided that other songs arnt as rare as CITR? It is just as rare except the person (people) who have it are on the messageboards. That doe NOT make the song any less "rare"

How many people have you talked to with Catcher in the Rye? I've talked to a lot of people. And they weren't lying.

How many people have you talked to with This I Love? Prostitute? Thyme? General?

Saying they just aren't on the message boards is idiotic. There are dozens of people with CITR on the message boards and a large number have come forward but NO ONE has even claimed to have any other songs (at least no one that could back up what they were saying)?

Seems unlikely. I think there are more copies of CITR floating around. Therefore, it is less rare.

Pretty soon we'll all have all of the songs at our local music store ?: ok:

Just think - after Axl and GN'R are long gone, years from now, "The Chinese Democracy Demos" will be released... "hundreds of hours' worth of never-before-heard material."

Axl has an entire library of Chinese Democracy demos, instrumental tracks, etc. That stuff will likely surface years from now as some sort of special box set.

nvm waht i said before, i got the wrong guy...this guy is full of it and jsut screwing up getting the song out there for everyone...and about the other track, yeah sry but i guess i was wrong

I don't doubt that he has Catcher, but I do doubt his intentions are to just "get the tracks out there." Not after he keeps spamming MyGNR with his trading posts and teasing "descriptions" of CITR which are both vague and insulting.

I'd post A TEXT Reply to these messages of a but people look at what i "WRITE" and use it against me on other forums.

PS sorry for the confusion.

i wont use it against you. do you really have those 5 unreleased tracks? cuz you know i probably dont

Catcher in the Rye probably sucks donkey balls  and it won't leak cause nobody wants even the slightest misfire. yeah that's it. the song sucks donkey balls.

I've actually wondered about that too. The song could be a real stinker.

mbenshoof4917: hows come there are no new leaks?
QuagulusOctavius: who is you?
mbenshoof4917: i asked you a long time ago about prosperous chili and you said there were gonna be leaks soon of other songs
mbenshoof4917: and there haven't been
QuagulusOctavius: are you retarded
QuagulusOctavius: that was a fricken lie
QuagulusOctavius: there is no prosperous chili
mbenshoof4917: no shit...but
mbenshoof4917: i thought you had others
QuagulusOctavius: hjahahaha
QuagulusOctavius: no
QuagulusOctavius: i don't even listen to GNR
QuagulusOctavius: doask forced me into this
mbenshoof4917: he lied too correct?
QuagulusOctavius: yeah
QuagulusOctavius: nothing is true
QuagulusOctavius: quote me on that
QuagulusOctavius: a lot ofpeople believd it tho
mbenshoof4917: no new news to me, you guys are real fuckin mature dude...no one believed you though............BLOCKED!

These are the type of dicks that make me a non-believer in all the " OMGZ I have th1s song" talk.

WHOAHHH WHOAAH WHOAAHHH I meant post a comment.

hahah! That's what made me think you had them jimb0 :hihi:

Dude, Sorry I fucked up.  If I had anything AT ALL.  All you motherfuckers would have it too, cuz we iz in this shit together...

As for the traders?  They could give a shit less.

Does anybody else find this thread absolutley pointless???

I Do  ;D 

i do and i keep fucking up and making ppl think someone has something

My question is.. why would you expect someone to trade General, This I Love, ect... for a song they probably have already? Im willing to bet that if someone had these other songs they have almost all the songs..

Also.. if CITR is less rare than the other songs... why would they trade for it? Last I checked you don't trade something thats less rare for something rare. You trade for something of equal value.

Im surprised no ones asked for 01.01.01 yet!  :hihi:

"I have CITR. Axl give me the Vegas DVD or I'll leak it."

I have General though and I'm not gonna leak it. 8)

"TheGreatOne" has nothing. As soon as I agreed to his "demands", he vanished.

Really.  Well, then why are all these assholes keeping it to themselves?

I believe TGO has it or at least part of it, obviously someone has it, why they are being reticent about sharing....I don't fully understand.

really?lol

No not really.    :'(

So who are these knuckleheads on these messageboards. lets get the song out there.  I'll offer a lot of extremely rare U2 songs. Anyone? nobody? What? U2's a great band. :hihi:

I've been online all day chief... where you at.

Like Einstein's General Theory of Relativity, there are challenges to it validity but when it is time to pony up, the theory remains unchallenged. There are no other songs other than CITR out there. We would have heard all of CITR if there were.

I hate to break this to you, but you are a figment of your own imagination?????..

I think its about time you fuck off Mr. Intensity...you're a lyin sack o' shit

where did bono get it?

(http://i51.photobucket.com/albums/f351/Grass666/GNRCRISIS.jpg)

Yeah, I get bored a lot.  Cheers to Bono!!!  :beer:

wow, the photoshops keep getting better

It may be close to the real thing if most posters could have their way................... :P

i can post a bunch of convos me and that quogulous octavious had about that song me and another friend knew he was bullshitting bc he said someone sent it to him and it had spyware attached whih is why he couldnt upload it i can post 2-3 full convos we had where he made up a ton of bullshit

Who really cares dude.................

Dude that is fukin funny!!!!!