|
Title: Where there's smoke there's fire.... Post by: Bono on February 28, 2006, 05:36:58 PM So is a reunion completely out of the question? Is it likely? Or maybe even inevitable? For the most part where's there's smoke there's fire. Just look at Hollywoood for example. Gossip magazines always tend to suggest celebrity breakups or hookups well before they happen and YES the gossip magazines are pretty much always right. Sooner or later the "rumors" they report come to fruition. So maybe it's not a matter of if Guns N' Roses reunite but simpley a matter of when. I'm starting to think it's gonna happen one way or another. When? That's the question.
I know this is just another reunion thread so if it gets removed so be it. Title: Re: Where there's smoke there's fire.... Post by: mikegiuliana on February 28, 2006, 05:38:44 PM it might happen one day but I doubt it will with all the money and hype around cd, axl has his own thing to prove before he can move on and rejoin his old band mates.. Right now I rather see this thing out before anything even happens..
See you in dead horse brother ;D Title: Re: Where there's smoke there's fire.... Post by: ppbebe on February 28, 2006, 05:41:31 PM Yeah but as the smoke has been there for so long with no fire, mate.....
Title: Re: Where there's smoke there's fire.... Post by: Bono on February 28, 2006, 05:47:54 PM Yeah but as the smoke has been there for so long with no fire, mate..... Not true. It's always been fan specualtion regarding a reunion, never so many mentions of it in actual articles. There's a shit load more smoke now than ever. I agree with Mike though, I don't see it happening untill Chinese Democracy is out of the way. The old band could no doubt still make amazing music together and I think everyone involed in the Gn'R camp, past, present and future realies how mega a reunion would be. But for now Vr did/is doing their thing and Axl needs to do his thing, after that I woudn't be surprised. Oha nd yeah see ya in Dead Horse. ;D I know this is a redundent topic but oh well. Title: Re: Where there's smoke there's fire.... Post by: mikegiuliana on February 28, 2006, 05:49:33 PM the reason I say no reunion is what would youi do with all the music axl and his guys did on this new album or possible albums to come?? We don't need axl starting anything from scratch now :rofl: :nervous:
Title: Re: Where there's smoke there's fire.... Post by: busngabb on February 28, 2006, 05:54:33 PM The only thing that gives this credit is the websites of the current supposed members.
Robin Finck denies all knowledge, as does Tommy Stinson, whilst Richard Fortus cries "Most certainly". Title: Re: Where there's smoke there's fire.... Post by: avesia on February 28, 2006, 05:56:27 PM the reason I say no reunion is what would youi do with all the music axl and his guys did on this new album or possible albums to come??? :nervous:...re-record it with the original members? ?:hihi: Title: Re: Where there's smoke there's fire.... Post by: The Dog on February 28, 2006, 06:00:44 PM Heres food for thought on a slow news day........
would you guys want to hear CD released NOW, or would you be willing to wait another year, 2 years if it was re-recorded with the old members? Title: Re: Where there's smoke there's fire.... Post by: mikegiuliana on February 28, 2006, 06:02:22 PM Heres food for thought on a slow news day........ would you guys want to hear CD released NOW, or would you be willing to wait another year, 2 years if it was re-recorded with the old members? Well if I knew the new guys would be there in two years I would take cd and the current lineup to support it.. I'm not interested in having the old gnr do all the new gnr's music.. Then the old guys could create something else.. Title: Re: Where there's smoke there's fire.... Post by: Gaymo, the Hobbit on February 28, 2006, 06:02:52 PM are you kidding me? i want it NOW...
Title: Re: Where there's smoke there's fire.... Post by: avesia on February 28, 2006, 06:03:49 PM Heres food for thought on a slow news day........ would you guys want to hear CD released NOW, or would you be willing to wait another year, 2 years if it was re-recorded with the old members? the old membrs wouldn't play these songs...first of all, it's not them!...and secondly, I don't se Slash or Izzy playing a bunch of songs they didn't bring their contribution to ?:no: Title: Re: Where there's smoke there's fire.... Post by: boston on February 28, 2006, 06:04:09 PM this new stuff is not hard, the solos are different, but slash could play it,
and the rythms, this is kindergraden stuff compared to old GNR, it is power chords- Slash will easily tear through this stuff Title: Re: Where there's smoke there's fire.... Post by: Bono on February 28, 2006, 06:06:31 PM Heres food for thought on a slow news day........ would you guys want to hear CD released NOW, or would you be willing to wait another year, 2 years if it was re-recorded with the old members? Shit no! I want Chinese Democracy as is before a reunion ever happens. I want to see what Axl can do. ?Mike as for what would they do with the new music Axl has come up with I'd think that if the old guys liked it and felt it rocked they'd have no problem playing it. ?They could always add their own touches durring the live performances. Plus Axl said 32 songs right? ?Maybe they'd just release the remaining songs that weren't on Chinese Democracy while on the CD tour(with the old band) and that way you'd have two Gn'R albums out within a year and then as soon as the tour was over the guys could get started on a new album with the old band's input. It works out perfect. Would actually make it seem in some weird way that the band had never broken up in the first place.Ha! I think I'm just living in LaLa land today :hihi: Title: Re: Where there's smoke there's fire.... Post by: Vicious Wishes on February 28, 2006, 06:13:17 PM the reason I say no reunion is what would youi do with all the music axl and his guys did on this new album or possible albums to come??? We don't need axl starting anything from scratch now :rofl: :nervous: True, we don't need Axl starting anything from scratch, but really...how could we tell the difference. :-\ Title: Re: Where there's smoke there's fire.... Post by: ElNonoPololo on February 28, 2006, 06:31:27 PM and YES the gossip magazines are pretty much always right. :rofl: Title: Re: Where there's smoke there's fire.... Post by: Steel_Angel on February 28, 2006, 06:34:08 PM when? 2007 ;D
Title: Re: Where there's smoke there's fire.... Post by: jimmythegent on February 28, 2006, 06:36:44 PM as long as the smoke isn't being blown up our asses? :hihi:
Title: Re: Where there's smoke there's fire.... Post by: ARC on February 28, 2006, 06:38:25 PM Axl, Slash and Duff, and maybe Izzy, will be on the same stage again one day. Not too sure about Steve.
Title: Re: Where there's smoke there's fire.... Post by: Wooody on February 28, 2006, 06:49:09 PM dead horse
Title: Re: Where there's smoke there's fire.... Post by: Gaymo, the Hobbit on February 28, 2006, 06:55:44 PM estranged
Title: Re: Where there's smoke there's fire.... Post by: brownstone658 on February 28, 2006, 06:57:07 PM A reunion is more likely than Axl getting back with the NuGnR band, I think (no buckethead, other members constantly revolving etc.). ?Have you noticed that none of those guys have talked to Axl recently, while Axl just spoke with Izzy on the phone? ?Also, VR is doing nothing right now- thats official, they pretty much aren't a band- and now the rumors of Slash reuniting with Axl, plus Halfin's comments- why is it so unlikely? ?Its been 10 years- people don't stay mad for that long, especially when money is involved. ?There is some smoke, my friends...
Title: Re: Where there's smoke there's fire.... Post by: Gaymo, the Hobbit on February 28, 2006, 06:58:49 PM how do you know the guys haven't talked to axl in a while? are you earl? or axl himself?
and what's that with bandmembers constantly revolving? not true Title: Re: Where there's smoke there's fire.... Post by: brownstone658 on February 28, 2006, 07:07:03 PM how do you know the guys haven't talked to axl in a while? are you earl? or axl himself? and what's that with bandmembers constantly revolving? not true Dizzy hasn't seen Axl. Why would anyone else? Bandmembers revolving not true? Are you kidding me? I don't have to defend that one. These people aren't stable units in the band. Its not like the old days when Slash, Duff, Izzy, Steve, and Axl would go get in bar fights together- its just a bunch of well paid seasoned pros getting together once in a while- I doubt they even got into the studio at the same time- listen to how many overdubs there are- and these guys have other projects and busy schedules! This isn't a band in the sense that the old GN'R was a band- they don't hang out- Axl has em over to record HIS songs. They haven't been together since MSG in '02. Personally, I see an original members reunion more likely. Title: Re: Where there's smoke there's fire.... Post by: Gaymo, the Hobbit on February 28, 2006, 07:09:50 PM so what you're saying is, when CD comes out, you're not going to buy it and won't visit any concerts?
alright then Title: Re: Where there's smoke there's fire.... Post by: brownstone658 on February 28, 2006, 07:15:01 PM so what you're saying is, when CD comes out, you're not going to buy it and won't visit any concerts? alright then When did I say that? I will buy it the second it comes out and I have already seen the new GNR in concert- Boston 02. I am just theorizing about the band, not judging it in any way. That made no sense whatsoever. Title: Re: Where there's smoke there's fire.... Post by: Bono on February 28, 2006, 07:24:53 PM and YES the gossip magazines are pretty much always right. :rofl: Laugh all you want but tell me one time where a gossip magazine continually ran story after story about certain couple's breakups or hookups based on "rumours" where it didn't eventually come true. Title: Re: Where there's smoke there's fire.... Post by: mikegiuliana on February 28, 2006, 08:02:43 PM Quote Also, VR is doing nothing right now- thats official, they pretty much aren't a band- It is true nothing offical as far as something coming out, but matt talked about writing for the album, duff has mentioned it, scott has mentioned it.. They had thrown a name around and even possible direction... They did tour all the way up until the new year which was only a fewmonths ago.. Can't always be busy with the band releasing wise Title: Re: Where there's smoke there's fire.... Post by: Sam on February 28, 2006, 09:46:29 PM Quote Also, VR is doing nothing right now- thats official, they pretty much aren't a band- It is true nothing offical as far as something coming out, but matt talked about writing for the album, duff has mentioned it, scott has mentioned it.. They had thrown a name around and even possible direction... They did tour all the way up until the new year which was only a fewmonths ago.. Can't always be busy with the band releasing wise ^^Reminds ya of the new Gn'R, huh?^^ Title: Re: Where there's smoke there's fire.... Post by: -Jack- on February 28, 2006, 09:51:05 PM Dude, Jarmo make a thread for noobs who wanna discuss the "Original GNR ARE coming back!" topic
"SLASH IS BACK! All the signs point to it!" "Axl LOVES SLASH!" "Buckethead is gone and NuGNR IS DEAD!" "VR arent on tour! They must be doing ABSOLUTLY NOTHING! ITS DEAD! SLASH LEFT" Come on.. theres been way too many threads like this. make an offical "reunion speculation" thread |