|
Title: Slash and Duff love to play with Matt - so why even think... Post by: GNRBABY on February 20, 2006, 07:40:52 PM If the original GNR reunites that they would have Steven back? Y'Know? It would be Axl,Slash,Duff,Izzy, Dizzy, and Matt for sure....I don't think they would have Gilby back unless Izzy said "no" either. Anything worth doing is worth doing it right :smoking: Adler would be the wrong choice IMO.
Thoughts...... Title: Re: Slash and Duff love to play with Matt - so why even think... Post by: BLS-Pride on February 20, 2006, 07:41:25 PM For the love of God it wont happen... Just stop.
Title: Re: Slash and Duff love to play with Matt - so why even think... Post by: mikegiuliana on February 20, 2006, 07:42:03 PM i think this is going to dead horse :D Maybe oen day it will happen, I myself want to se this play out with new gnr first
Title: Re: Slash and Duff love to play with Matt - so why even think... Post by: Markus Asraelius on February 20, 2006, 07:42:25 PM The horse is dead! :drool:
Title: Re: Slash and Duff love to play with Matt - so why even think... Post by: GNRBABY on February 20, 2006, 07:43:03 PM For the love of God it wont happen... Just stop. :hihi: :hihi:....It's ok to dream...Maybe this thread should be in DEAD HORSE! :hihi: Title: Re: Slash and Duff love to play with Matt - so why even think... Post by: mikegiuliana on February 20, 2006, 07:52:24 PM just to answer the question is if they were to reunite as in afd gnr it doesn't matter who they like better it's about those 5
I really pray it happens one day after this new gnr runs it's course.. I can ejoy two eras, just so much time waiting for this one Title: Re: Slash and Duff love to play with Matt - so why even think... Post by: DoubleTalkingJive on February 20, 2006, 07:57:05 PM Okay I have a question.....Lets say the old GNR reunited...do you think people would be so hard on and criticize Axl's voice. The first thing I hear from non die hards is Axl voice sucks, it's lost it's edge...but do you think if the fab 5 got back they would still harp on that?
Title: Re: Slash and Duff love to play with Matt - so why even think... Post by: mikegiuliana on February 20, 2006, 08:00:10 PM Okay I have a question.....Lets say the old GNR reunited...do you think people would be so hard on and criticize Axl's voice.? ?The first thing I hear from non die hards is Axl voice sucks, it's lost it's edge...but do you think if the fab 5 got back they would still harp on that? yeah I do, I think when you disappear for that long and you age people just pick on any old thing.. if he would have aged in front of us it wouldn't have mattered nor would his vast change in apperance Title: Re: Slash and Duff love to play with Matt - so why even think... Post by: Bridge on February 20, 2006, 08:03:16 PM there's a dead horse in the middle of the road, stinkin to high heaven
Title: Re: Slash and Duff love to play with Matt - so why even think... Post by: destroier on February 20, 2006, 08:20:13 PM No way Axl would play with Matt. It would be someone entirely different.
Title: Re: Slash and Duff love to play with Matt - so why even think... Post by: GNRBABY on February 20, 2006, 09:37:05 PM No way Axl would play with Matt. It would be someone entirely different. I halfway agree with you on that. I have always gotten the impression Matt hates Axl nad Axl hates Matt. After that VH1 behind the music... Title: Re: Slash and Duff love to play with Matt - so why even think... Post by: Mr.Bootlegs on February 21, 2006, 10:50:22 AM Okay I have a question.....Lets say the old GNR reunited...do you think people would be so hard on and criticize Axl's voice. The first thing I hear from non die hards is Axl voice sucks, it's lost it's edge...but do you think if the fab 5 got back they would still harp on that? yeah I do, I think when you disappear for that long and you age people just pick on any old thing.. if he would have aged in front of us it wouldn't have mattered nor would his vast change in apperance Any old thing??. If his voice were just 'any old thing' then he would be performing mute and you wouldnt care. His voice is like the main thing that we wanna see him keep intact. And im not 'bashing' Axl here either, i'm just sayinduring the '02 tour he basically sucked voice-wise. (and ive seen/heard almost every show on that tour.) Title: Re: Slash and Duff love to play with Matt - so why even think... Post by: jmapelian on February 21, 2006, 04:59:31 PM well he's had plenty of time to rest his voice since then :hihi:
But friends of mine said the same thing about his voice after the recent leaks I played for them.....basically his voice is shit and ait's annoying.....oh, and the music sucks too Title: Re: Slash and Duff love to play with Matt - so why even think... Post by: Sweet s on February 22, 2006, 07:39:25 AM I would say Steven as he is the original one : ok:
The Classic GN'R lineup of Axl Slash Izzy Duff Steven for me Title: Re: Slash and Duff love to play with Matt - so why even think... Post by: Carlos_f_Rose on February 22, 2006, 08:27:59 AM I would say SWEET S' list of members is the same for me...
And I wouldnt add Dizzy Reed. Title: Re: Slash and Duff love to play with Matt - so why even think... Post by: Sweet s on February 22, 2006, 09:05:23 AM I do have mixed feelings about steven because i prefer Matt as a drummer,But I so think Stevie deserves to be in there :)
Title: Re: Slash and Duff love to play with Matt - so why even think... Post by: SourBaby on February 22, 2006, 10:19:20 AM Yeah they should can the Steven idea if they reunite.. I like matt better!!! :drool:
Title: Re: Slash and Duff love to play with Matt - so why even think... Post by: J? on February 22, 2006, 11:51:03 AM Adler is still a huge junkie, so I don't think he would ever be back. Plus he loves shit talking Axl alot and I don't think Axl is too fond of Mr. Adler.
Title: Re: Slash and Duff love to play with Matt - so why even think... Post by: GNRBABY on February 22, 2006, 12:49:20 PM I would say Steven as he is the original one : ok: The Classic GN'R lineup of Axl Slash Izzy Duff Steven? for me If GNR reunited I doubt it would be those 5. Dizzy and Matt would be there for they could only play AFD and Lies if not. Hell, I'd consider Slash,Duff, and Axl a reunion....That would be good enough.... Title: Re: Slash and Duff love to play with Matt - so why even think... Post by: Megaguns on February 23, 2006, 05:18:50 AM i hope they do it sooner than later. id rather see mid forties guys on stage than mid fiftys or sixtys.
Title: Re: Slash and Duff love to play with Matt - so why even think... Post by: Sweet s on February 23, 2006, 08:05:01 AM Mid-Sixties ;)
You are getting into Rolling Stones land then >:( |