Here Today... Gone To Hell!

if just one old gnr member would come back. who would you want it to be.

       ME   IZZY

Agreed but still moving forward........

buckethead.  : ok:

 with out a doubt Izzy.

Me too, or Gilby

This will be deadhorsed or probably deleted so I'll quickly say that Izzy should be the old member to come back. Maybe then Axl could finish CD! LMAO!!

Buckethead :love:

slash.. The most known duo in the eyes of gnr is them two..

they are like jagger richards, perry tyler, page plant, etc

Agreed : ok: I was  close to saying the same thing .

Ill take Izzy, but if I could pull a switcharoo, Id kick Dizzys the fuck out and get Slash in their too.

Slash or Izzy.

Yes, Slash is the man.  :yes:

Slash Indeed. : ok:

Shaq... ;D :hihi: :hihi:
Nah, Slash definetly

Slash or Duff.

I'd have to say....Izzy : ok:

Oh... damn... this is a tough question for me...

I'd want Izzy because he is responsible for writing my favorite songs.
But then, I'd want Buckethead, because he's an amazing guitarist.
And... well... I guess there's a part of me that resides within that would love to see Axl and Slash back together.  I realize this isn't going to happen, I've accepted it... but, it's like someone else said ^^^  Axl & Slash are a great duo, like Perry & Tyler and  Page & Plant.  The friction between them created the phenomenon and magic.

I still think Buckethead is a better guitarist than Slash... **ducking to avoid things being thrown in my direction** but, I don't deny the magic between Axl & Slash.

Buckethead better than Slash?? Gimme a fuckin break!! Try to imagine 'Estranged', 'November Rain', 'Sweet Child O Mine', etc. without Slash!

I knew that would piss off at least one person.   :hihi:

I'll go with Izzy.  That way at least they'd get some new material out and it would probably be good.  Also I always considered Izzy to be the least likely to come back, so if he did I think it would go a long way in convincing the rest to come back.

I would chose Slash and then i think Duff would came along because they are so close plus duff sad that he would reunite with GNR . So we would have the 3 of them and then i think Izzy and Steven would? come long!!! And then the line-up for "the most dangerous band in the world" would be complete. : ok:

Definately Izzy. The creative drive ended when Izzy left. Not alot of original guns songs came out after he went.... Just those "new band" songs

Actually, the only original song that GNR has released in the 14 years since Izzy's departure is 'Oh My God'. Incredibly hard to believe that the world's greatest band has this track record, but its true.

I thought Oh my god was the only one, But it does kick ass.

Slash : ok: