|
Title: STP and GNR songs you'd like VR to play Post by: RichardNixon on February 22, 2005, 07:48:13 PM For STP: All of these would sound killer with a Slash solo : ok: :peace:
1. Sour Girl 2. Big Bang Baby 3. Trippin on a hole in a Paper Heart 4. Down And for GN'R 1. 14 Years- That's one of GN'R finest songs, IMHO, and it would be a real surprise. 2. Locomotive- Scott could pull it off great. 3. Dead Horse. 4. Novemer Rain- Yes, it's an Axl song, but the crowd would go nuts. Title: Re: STP and GNR songs you'd like VR to play Post by: Dave_Rose on February 22, 2005, 08:16:05 PM November Rain by VR I dont think I have to say anything here :no:
The only GN'R song I could imagine VR doing out of you're list is Dead Horse Those songs from gn'r are about where Slash, Matt n Duff have been not where they are going I think VR guys have chosen the STP and GN'R songs to do Title: Re: STP and GNR songs you'd like VR to play Post by: Malcolm on February 22, 2005, 08:21:48 PM Good Topic dude..Stp Songs: Sour Girl, Days Of The Week,Plush
GNR Songs: So Fine would be awsome..Scott would have no problem singing Axl's parts YCBM My Michelle Title: Re: STP and GNR songs you'd like VR to play Post by: Izzy on February 22, 2005, 08:35:35 PM I think Dead Horse would be an idea, i don't actually think VR should do any more stuff that isn't there's originally, but its only a hypothetical thread anyway.
Maybe they could do 'Since i don't have u' and dedicate it to Axl :hihi: Title: Re: STP and GNR songs you'd like VR to play Post by: Eclipsed107 on February 22, 2005, 08:54:54 PM STP
Down Crackerman Heaven and Hotrods Sex Type Thing No Sex or Violence Silvergun Superman Gn'R It's So Easy Out Ta Get Me Mr. Brownstone My Michelle You're Crazy (slow - but electric) Don't Damn Me I think VR could do any of those songs kick-ass.? 2 - 4 a night would be nice, along with a lloonngg VR set..maybe (and yes I know they do some of these songs, they're good choices for the band!) Title: Re: STP and GNR songs you'd like VR to play Post by: Eclipsed107 on February 22, 2005, 09:02:46 PM Oh and out of the already mentioned songs...
1. Sour Girl 2. Big Bang Baby 3. Trippin on a hole in a Paper Heart 4. Down 5. Days Of The Week, 6. Plush 1. 14 Years 2. Locomotive 3. Dead Horse 4. Novemer Rain 5. So Fine 6. YCBM 7. My Michelle The only songs I could imagen VR doing from that 13 song list is..Trippin' on a hole in a paper heart (but probably not), down, plush (i guess, but it's so cliche and overrated) and my michelle. The others just don't fit the VR style, espechally Sour Girl and Days of the Week (way way too much pop for VR) Big Banb Baby (my fave. stp song btw) ,Dead Horse, November Rain, and So Fine... Title: Re: STP and GNR songs you'd like VR to play Post by: gnrvrrule on February 22, 2005, 09:23:27 PM Double Talkin' Jive, and I've said this before, would be a great song for VR. Scott's vocals fit this song pretty perfectly. Unfortunately, and someone tell me if I'm wrong, by law they may not be able to play this song, unless they got approval from Izzy Stradlin, who wrote this song. Now I know bands, including VR, play cover songs from other bands, but technically are they not allowed to do that? If they were to play November Rain or Estranged, which are solely Axl's songs, I'm sure Uncle Axl would flip.
Title: Re: STP and GNR songs you'd like VR to play Post by: Booker Floyd on February 22, 2005, 09:53:21 PM Ideally, Id love to see "You Could Be Mine" and "Trippin' On A Hole..."
The likelihood of that happening is very small, so realistically Id like to see "Anything Goes," "Nightrain," or maybe "My Michelle." On the STP end, Id love to see "Army Ants," "Down," or "Vasoline." "Big Empty" and "Plush" are unlikely, but equally welcome. Title: Re: STP and GNR songs you'd like VR to play Post by: tomass74 on February 22, 2005, 09:59:13 PM I won't list the songs they already do. I really enjoy the covers of STP and Gn'R they do in the shows as long as they keep them to about 5 or 6.
STP ------- Wicked Garden Plush Dead and Bloated Art School Girl Sour Girl Trippin On A Hole Gn'R ---------- Paradise City Rocket Queen You're Crazy (Slow Tempo) Title: Re: STP and GNR songs you'd like VR to play Post by: jgfnsr on February 22, 2005, 10:48:29 PM I don't think he'd ever desire to so I guess it's mute, but there's no way Scott could ever pull off "November Rain."
Title: Re: STP and GNR songs you'd like VR to play Post by: Falcon on February 22, 2005, 10:54:15 PM I don't think he'd ever desire to so I guess it's mute, but there's no way Scott could ever pull off "November Rain." Nor would he want to. Title: Re: STP and GNR songs you'd like VR to play Post by: Acquiesce on February 23, 2005, 12:23:19 AM GNR:
Don't Damn Me STP: Down Title: Re: STP and GNR songs you'd like VR to play Post by: tomass74 on February 23, 2005, 01:11:49 AM hahah, hell no would he wouldn't want to. That song was ok back in the day but that was then this is now.
Title: Re: STP and GNR songs you'd like VR to play Post by: Skyscraper on February 23, 2005, 06:23:18 AM For STP: All of these would sound killer with a Slash solo : ok: :peace: 1. Sour Girl 2. Big Bang Baby 3. Trippin on a hole in a Paper Heart 4. Down And for GN'R 1. 14 Years- That's one of GN'R finest songs, IMHO, and it would be a real surprise. 2. Locomotive- Scott could pull it off great. 3. Dead Horse. 4. Novemer Rain- Yes, it's an Axl song, but the crowd would go nuts. Great songs... but i cant imagine nov rain sung by scott... i will kike to hear Plush, MC5 and All in the Suit That You Wear of STP... Title: Re: STP and GNR songs you'd like VR to play Post by: Genesis on February 23, 2005, 08:14:08 AM GNR: Not even GN'R played that live.Don't Damn Me Title: Re: STP and GNR songs you'd like VR to play Post by: McClane on February 23, 2005, 08:37:18 AM I really think that Scott can sing almost all GNR songs and it would be very good...Did you notice in the toronto bootleg how Scott sound very similar to Axl in It's so easy and Mr.Brownstone...
I don't want VR to play the GNR singles or the most popular GNR songs, I just want something that we didn't heard 100 times live and something that would fit with Scott on vocals... So here's my wishlist: STP: Interstate love song Big Bang Baby Sour Girl (and keep Crakerman and Sex Type thing in the setlist) GNR: Double talkin Jive (Scott would nail that one) You're crazy (Scott voice would fit well) Dust N' Bones (great song live, it would fit for VR) Locomotive (would be just great) You could be mine ( I know it's a GNR single but it would kick ass !) (and keep It's so easy and Mr.Brownstone in the setlist) Title: Re: STP and GNR songs you'd like VR to play Post by: Mikkamakka on February 23, 2005, 02:58:45 PM ISE, Nightrain, Out ta get me, Mr. Brownstone, Reckless Life, UTLH, Dust N' Bones... but I'd rather new VR material :yes:
Title: Re: STP and GNR songs you'd like VR to play Post by: StoneTempleRoses on February 23, 2005, 08:59:03 PM Out ta Get Me, Silvergun Superman, Breakdown : ok:
StoneTempleRoses Title: Re: STP and GNR songs you'd like VR to play Post by: Acquiesce on February 24, 2005, 12:49:31 AM GNR: Not even GN'R played that live.Don't Damn Me Yeah, I know. That's part of the reason why I would like to see them do it if they are going to continue to do GNR songs. Title: Re: STP and GNR songs you'd like VR to play Post by: jimmythegent on February 24, 2005, 01:38:56 AM The only one i'd really like to hear them do is Double Talkin' Jive : ok:
Title: Re: STP and GNR songs you'd like VR to play Post by: Drew on February 24, 2005, 05:49:27 PM GN'R:
1. 14 Years - w/special guest Izzy Stradlin on vocals : ok: 2. Rocket Queen 3. You Could Be Mine 4. My Michelle STP: 1. Interstate Love Song Title: Re: STP and GNR songs you'd like VR to play Post by: Wheres Izzy on February 24, 2005, 07:43:32 PM I am only putting the songs I am pretty sure they havn't done so favorites like crackerman, used to love her, it's so easy aren't listed.
GnR songs- Double talkin jive (I'd rather hear them do that than anything else) Rocket Queen Nice Boys Dust n Bones 14 years Get in the ring STP songs- SIlver gun superman Lady picture show Trippin on a hole in a paper heart Kitchenware and candy bars sex and violence wonderful still remains Title: Re: STP and GNR songs you'd like VR to play Post by: jgfnsr on February 24, 2005, 10:42:03 PM I don't think he'd ever desire to so I guess it's mute, but there's no way Scott could ever pull off "November Rain." Nor would he want to. Is there an echo in here? Read the first part of the sentence Falcon... : ok: Title: Re: STP and GNR songs you'd like VR to play Post by: Stokesy on February 25, 2005, 04:22:40 AM I'd love to here:
Think About You Rocket Queen Civil War You COuld Be Mine Title: Re: STP and GNR songs you'd like VR to play Post by: usurper on February 25, 2005, 06:17:41 AM I dont want VR playing any GNR songs, but thats my opinion, if you saw Scott trying to sing Brownstone I think you would know, it is just not the fucking same.
Title: Re: STP and GNR songs you'd like VR to play Post by: Booker Floyd on February 25, 2005, 10:59:05 AM I dont want VR playing any GNR songs, but thats my opinion, if you saw Scott trying to sing Brownstone I think you would know, it is just not the fucking same. 1)Not really the topic 2) Youre in the minority 3) He does a great job Title: Re: STP and GNR songs you'd like VR to play Post by: usurper on February 25, 2005, 11:08:48 AM I dont want VR playing any GNR songs, but thats my opinion, if you saw Scott trying to sing Brownstone I think you would know, it is just not the fucking same. 1)Not really the topic 2) Youre in the minority 3) He does a great job whatever buddy, fool yourself :yes: Title: Re: STP and GNR songs you'd like VR to play Post by: D on February 25, 2005, 02:23:31 PM NONE
realisticiallyhe couldnt play hardly any of those GNR songs u guys mentioned there is no way in hell he could sing the end of rocket queen or my michelle or you could be mine I think they should in the future distance themselves as much as possible from GNR songs to be honest maybe play Its So Easy cause thats bout the only one that sounds good when they do it. Title: Re: STP and GNR songs you'd like VR to play Post by: Mikkamakka on February 25, 2005, 03:34:11 PM NONE realisticiallyhe couldnt play hardly any of those GNR songs u guys mentioned there is no way in hell he could sing the end of rocket queen or my michelle or you could be mine I think they should in the future distance themselves as much as possible from GNR songs to be honest maybe play Its So Easy cause thats bout the only one that sounds good when they do it. I mostly agree. There is no singer on the world who could interpret the classic GN'R songs on they way they should be. Title: Re: STP and GNR songs you'd like VR to play Post by: D on February 26, 2005, 02:56:10 AM i just think if u are gonna do a cover song it should be as good as the original.
doin GNR songs even its so easy, at the end with the high pitched "its so easy, so fuckin easy, its so easy" when scott does the megaphone it just isnt anywhere close to as possible. Title: Re: STP and GNR songs you'd like VR to play Post by: Mikkamakka on February 26, 2005, 05:09:11 AM i just think if u are gonna do a cover song it should be as good as the original. doin GNR songs even its so easy, at the end with the high pitched "its so easy, so fuckin easy, its so easy" when scott does the megaphone it just isnt anywhere close to as possible. Or even better or you make a very different version of the song (although that's still supposed to be good). BTW I think that VR's Brownstone and Easy are good covers, very close to the originals. Title: Re: STP and GNR songs you'd like VR to play Post by: azazello on February 28, 2005, 03:00:09 PM Erm, why do u ppl believe covers are sposed to be exact reproductions of the originals? That's why they are covers, not tribute songs.
And I'd say they should do Don't Damn Me. Lyrically, perfect for the attitude of Scott, and it's not that high vocally. Plus its one of the superb GN'R songs, and it would be soooo cool to do a song that has _never_ been performed live by the old band. Title: Re: STP and GNR songs you'd like VR to play Post by: Jim Bob on February 28, 2005, 03:31:14 PM i dont think they should do any gnr songs. it doesn't sound right without Axl's voice, and aren't they always saying they want to distance themselves from their gnr past :rofl:
Whoever said Dead Horse, that is 100% Axl's song.. if they played that they would look like fools. oh wait. Title: Re: STP and GNR songs you'd like VR to play Post by: Mikkamakka on February 28, 2005, 04:25:17 PM Erm, why do u ppl believe covers are sposed to be exact reproductions of the originals? That's why they are covers, not tribute songs.? I didn't mean that and I agree with you. I only said that these GN'R covers (tribute songs ;D) sounded like the old GN'R would have played. But it'd have been strange if Slash & Co had turned Brownstone or Easy to a death metal or orchestra song. Title: Re: STP and GNR songs you'd like VR to play Post by: AxlStaleyWeiland on February 28, 2005, 05:24:04 PM Garden of Eden,
Title: Re: STP and GNR songs you'd like VR to play Post by: mrlee on February 28, 2005, 05:25:44 PM apart from VR already palying my favourite GNR songs i would like them to do double talkin jive, maybe duff could do one of those punk covers they did, right next door to hell, perfect crime. I think they did november rain didnt they? was it in the cardiff show? maybe im completely mistaken.
Title: Re: STP and GNR songs you'd like VR to play Post by: Falcon on February 28, 2005, 06:45:01 PM I think they did november rain didnt they? was it in the cardiff show? maybe im completely mistaken. Nope. You're completely mistaken. Title: Re: STP and GNR songs you'd like VR to play Post by: Mikkamakka on March 01, 2005, 02:44:35 AM I think they did november rain didnt they? was it in the cardiff show? maybe im completely mistaken. Nope. You're completely mistaken. We had this rumour some weeks ago, but was only a rumour. VR playing NR is something that won't ever happen. Title: Re: STP and GNR songs you'd like VR to play Post by: Falcon on March 01, 2005, 01:21:14 PM VR playing NR is something that won't ever happen. And I thank the rock Gods for that. Title: Re: STP and GNR songs you'd like VR to play Post by: mrlee on March 03, 2005, 04:15:02 PM maybe they could do right next door to hell, deep version?
Title: Re: STP and GNR songs you'd like VR to play Post by: deliverthecow on March 03, 2005, 11:38:54 PM I am anxious for another VR album so they have more material for the live setting so they can distance themselves form GnR and STP. I actually think they have done a good job with the few that they have been playing, pretty good choices. If i had to pick i think it would be killer to see VR do 14 Years with Stradlin. As for STP i think Hollywood Bitch would be a cool choice.
Title: Re: STP and GNR songs you'd like VR to play Post by: RichardNixon on March 03, 2005, 11:58:23 PM How about VR doing "One in a Million." :hihi:
Title: Re: STP and GNR songs you'd like VR to play Post by: Mikkamakka on March 04, 2005, 03:09:13 AM How about VR doing "One in a Million." :hihi: And November Rain, SCOM, Look at your Game Girl, My World, Since I don't have you... Title: Re: STP and GNR songs you'd like VR to play Post by: hyperionmax2003 on March 04, 2005, 02:13:39 PM What about GNR's Nightrain?
Title: Re: STP and GNR songs you'd like VR to play Post by: mrlee on March 05, 2005, 07:53:07 AM nah scotts voice isnt powefull enough. Since you cant really hear him when he sings i used to love her so im guessing that.
Title: Re: STP and GNR songs you'd like VR to play Post by: Sakib on March 06, 2005, 12:34:16 PM STP-Vasoline
GN'R-Dont damn me Title: Re: STP and GNR songs you'd like VR to play Post by: tomass74 on March 07, 2005, 09:35:32 PM I dont want VR playing any GNR songs, but thats my opinion, if you saw Scott trying to sing Brownstone I think you would know, it is just not the fucking same. 1)Not really the topic 2) Youre in the minority 3) He does a great job I agree that he sings them great, Brownstone and It's So Easy....It's not Axl but he sings them just as powerful and he sounds just fine. |