Here Today... Gone To Hell!

do you hear the difference and can tell which guy it is hearin a solo...?
i noticed i hear who's playin almost everytime, at least i think so  :nervous:

i bet this is buckethead doin the solo after axl's ohnono-part (axl sings good too  :) )
http://s14.yousendit.com/d.aspx?id=13BY3154C0Y8L03NQJBN1U8RCB
am i right about thats buckethead?

this goes 4 all songs  :peace: can you tell?

Buck solo's from 2:44 to 2:57...

-PEACE-

Norway, all do respect bud, but you've got to be kidding me, bucket was sucking if thats supost to be better than Slash. You can tell by the way Axl is singing, there's hardly any energy or feeling coming from the one guitar and Axl. I know the energy will be there with the new stuff.  maybe if we had a studio version of the new guys with old AFD songs we could tell the real difference.  that would be something to talk about.

Then shut up...

-PEACE-

Lets not get that way Slipdisc I'm not knocking Bucket or anybody here thats just my opinion I've come to share. have some class, don't.

thanks slipdisc  :D
yes of course opinions are fine and you don't think axl or bucket was soundin good, oki  :)
but when listenin to boots, do you hear which guitarplayer is playin withou seein the video?

btw, i think axl sounded raw in that recordin  ;)

Fun, I like sound threads like this.  :D
Obviously This is no way "old vs new" or "who?s the better" shit, but just a fun fun Sorta Musical quiz, right?
Yeah, he sounds raw here. I haven't ever listened to it note by note this carefully. Hmm.

(btw, complete off topic but my mouse is fucked up.)

 ::)


 :hihi:


Have some clues...

-PEACE-

PS. Don't talk to me about class, take your celebrity deathmatches to the deadhorse section. Class would be if for once a pefectly good thread wouldn't be turned into a Buckethead vs. Slash discussion within 4 posts. It was nice the first 250 times (and I joined in with great pleasure), but the last half year people seem to get real tired of it.

eat chicken

Are your parents siblings?

-PEACE-

Slipdisc and Luigi, stop the name calling please. This is not junior high school.

I didn't call anybody any name...I was merely showing some interest.... :hihi:? :rofl:

So please leave me out of this whatever you think you're on to here...

-PEACE-

Ok Pandora, sorry. Slipdisc I know we can agree on one thing.......... GNR Shuts the fucken door

Damn right!!!? : ok:


Sorry?? I don't remember you calling anybody any name in this thread .... Dude, don't apologize for something you didn't even do to begin with.... ;)

-PEACE-

Robin's doing the solo when Axl is doing the "wha-oh, wha-no-no-no" part, and then Bucket kicks in with his solo after the "Let me see you fuckin' try!". It's extremely easy for me to tell the difference. Robin's playing is looser, while Bucket's is extreme shredding. Richard's somewhere in the middle...

100% right. :yes:

For me too. I can tell you the difference any time, even with some pans change. Finck has a lot of overdrive, Bucket and Richard are more into compressor and delay...

I still don't know if Robin will be on right speaker (like in SCOM 99) or left (like those Boston Promos). The soundboards bootlegs didn't help, it changes from each bootleg (maybe it's some encode mistake). But he's on the right side of the stage (public point view), just like Slash....
Buckethead and Fortus shares the other speaker, but Bucket's guitar is really loud when he plays a solo - even if in The Blues I barely hear Bucket playing some "bass notes" only on the chorus.
Fortus rhythm guitar is always low in The Blues chorus, but in the Osaka boot (or Tokyo?) I can hear him better - and his guitar work is awesome!  : ok:

yeah, but after axl says whoah, nono, he says let me see you fucking try right after, and then comes buckethead?

:idea: during whanono, is richard?

Yep. :yes:


No, it's still Robin. :headbanger:

damn i bad at this, got buckethead right and richard tho? :D sometimes it sounds like finc is stoppin tones to me (like gearing a lot)
and the stuff he does b4 pc is i hear thats him... very often i can hear (without seein) who's playin? :)

damn you good at this  : ok:

Norway, I just listened to it again, buckethead tore it up, that guy completely shreads notes by note simultaneously. robin on the other hand ? ...

i see, good ears? : ok: very technical advanced but some loss of melody- robin didn't do so bad? :)
uhm is tore it up and shreds notes a good thing?

this is my fav solo from buckethead on old gnr so far, very melodic and listenerfriendly-
so cool when he looks up when the fast parts starts...
http://www.newgnr.com/dloads/shortclips/bhntrain.wmv


yes, funfunfun? :D know your gnr guitarist? ;)
btw, this is complete off topic but mouse means pussy in my language? :coffee:
have a cat? :peace:

I love Buckethead's renditions of the nightrain solo.... It was so amazing to hear him play it at Pukkelpop and at the Docklands.  : ok:

-PEACE-

Oh yea! shread, tear and tore it up, that's a good thing.

those two are my favs shows? :D + japan
since there's no video of japan i have to guess who playes what? :nervous:
doin "ok" so far

Norway, do you have any other guitar solos of guns you can share? or videos

he's my fav too,? :peace: exept buckethead, imo rich sounds more bluesy and classic rock, like it? :yes:
closest to slash soundwise (from the boots) of the guitarist 2 me...

newgnr has a section called shortclips where you can check the solo's played by each? : ok:

Agreed. His November Rain solo is closer to the original played by Slash than when Finck played the first solo. I liked the Finck version, though.  :yes:
Can you hear Finck's guitar work in Madagascar while Bucket plays the solo? I think it's really cool. And just after this, he plays some power chords and goes to the ending of Bucket's solo playing some high notes and kick off with the wha-wha riff when Axl starts to sing again. I tried to play as near as possibile like him in my Maddie cover (you can download it HERE (http://www.14yearsofsilence.com/madagascar(mix-final-128k).mp3) - thanks to rnx!).
The 3 guitars line-up rocked so much. Hope they can put someone to replace Bucket and keep their 3 guitar work.  :peace:

i thought the high notes that lasts long was richard-

- (u usually hear it after held togehter )and a high note is played after and lasts a while b4 rythm prepare you 4 the solo...

after the solo when axl sings again i hear the high notes again, which i though was richard, not?
not yet, i'll check it out, which show has the best sound 4 that, listening to osaka (axl says tokyo? :hihi:) now...

yeah, and the variations in the guitar sound? :beer:

Yes, this is Richard but I wasn't talking about this. I was talking about when the solo is ending and when Axl starts to sing. Richard does play a riff with high notes, but Finck plays another thing at the same time.

Yes, this is Richard, as I said above.

Try the Tacoma or Idaho soundboards. If u don't have the Idaho one, just right click HERE (http://d14.yousendit.com/C/090M8K68D1JDD08R7G8SGSMIL6/renamed_Guns+N'+Roses+-+Idaho+'02+-+05+-+Madagascar+-+soundboard+-+www.newgnr.com.mp3)  ;)
If it does not work, try this link: http://s14.yousendit.com/d.aspx?id=090M8K68D1JDD08R7G8SGSMIL6
With regular bootlegs, I guess I can only hear it in one of the Leeds audio bootlegs.

got idaho? ;) thanks,
i really like bucketheads maddy- solosection on idaho most (of 02),? most likely thats buckethead i heard,? :confused:
it even sounds like a different filter or distortion...

fuck there's so much details in the shows you notice after a while, fx, the begining of mr-brownstone among others
and chris's contributions too? :drool:
ps\ post if you get the solo right?? :beer:

Don't nitpick on the word "name-calling" please.
"Are your parents siblings?" is the kind of stupid insult I heard at school when I was 12. Are you 12?

You did that?!?  :o Dude, you kick ass! Sounds really amazing.

I didn't understand... What solo?
Yeah, I love to hear to the bootlegs (sb or not) to search for new details... And this new band has a lot of it!

Thanks dude!  :beer:

Don't nitpick on me.... use IM for trivial BS like this.
If you meant something else then you should have said something else.


Aha so much has happened in this thread, but you had to bring things up again. Can't seem to let go can you? ..... Now that's childish.


Are you bored?
It sure seems like it.... People with too much time on their hands tend to see problems where there are none.

-PEACE-

you're working on the blues aren't you?

i downloaded your madagscar some weeks ago (suppose the same in this thread) very good,
sounded a lil'l like jimi hendrix sound, intrestin  : ok:

Oh, that was in another thread.  ;D
Yeah, I'm working on the blues, but I've been so lazy lately...
My hardest work will be learn the Richard's rhythm on the chorus. It's very hard to hear, but I know he's playing something more than power chords... Actually, I can see him playing something different in the bootlegs.
Hey, thanks for downloading my madagascar cover.  ;)

oki, who's doing the riff at the begining of each show? bet it's finc...

The WTTJ riff? It's Finck!  : ok:
That's a hard one: who is playing the high notes while Axl sing the chorus in Rhiad?

a tougher one, whats the chorus in rhiad?  :nervous:

When he sings "ooh.. my salvation... and oooh.. my frustration.."

richard? the guitartonalty sounds like it, dunno the playing,
do you know the answer??

Yeah, I know! But it's not Richard...  :no:
But he plays the opening riff, I guess.  ;)

ok, that was a tough one... yo, those who answers maybe back up why?  :D
that would be a nice touch :peace:

Ok: it's Finck who plays the high notes on Rhiad's chorus. You can tell it because of the slow and full bends and his tonality.  Also, Buckethead didn't play the chorus, he only plays the heavy parts, the solo and that kind of tremolo ending. Richard plays the flat and clean guitar with some full chords ;)

Richard has a kick-ass guitar, that's also why he sounds so great. Nothing can beat a Gibson ES-335 : ok:

(http://www.guitare-village.com/matos/02_12_2003/335.jpg)

He didn't use this guitar in any of the new songs...   :no:
But he played pretty damn good with this ES-335 on Rocket Queen!  :smoking:

did he use that bantubi on the tour?

anyone heard the axl rose-scream on oh my god? if you listen carefully you hear it, it's very deep in the mix
oh, if it open your eyes i wouldn't bet on a good comprimese
i was willing 2 be lost in the shuffle is only you had let me know

second time:


oh, if it open your eyes i wouldn't bet on a good comprimese
the scream starts here...
i was willing 2 be lost in the shuffle is only you had let me know- after know you'll hear the end of the scream in the background ends "whoah" and the beginnin thing starts? :)

it's pretty cool, has emotional note change... hope they level it higher if it's released again? :peace:


ps\sorry 4 fuckin up the lyrics...

You can hear it on the no-vocals version made by some fan... It's pretty cool, actually. You can hear some guitar shreding behind Axl "and the won't give in cause they know.."... So much stuff there but everyting sounds like a mess in the mix. It could be way better...  :-[

These new songs have so many layers it's not even funny. I swear, nearly everytime I listen to a song, I hear something new. People give shit about "why do they need 3 guitars and 2 keyboards" but the layering and texturing in these songs is mind boggling. 'Madagascar', for example, there are SO MANY different strings and loops going on throughout the entire song, it's amazing. No wonder the record has taken so long. It must take them 2 months to get a full song in a final mix, but I'm not complaining...