|
Title: STEVE VS MATT, IZZY VS GILBY Post by: groupie on January 16, 2005, 05:23:48 PM both steve and izzy left the band. steve left in 1990 and izzy did so a year later.
so who's better? steve or matt, izzy or gilby?don't make me even start with slash and buckethead 'cause in my opinion slash is the best guitar player in the world. opinions? :-* :-* :-* :-* :-* :-* :-* :-* :-* :-* :-* :-* :-* :-* :-* :-* :-* :-* :-* :-* :-* :-* :-* :-* :-* Title: Re: STEVE VS MATT, IZZY VS GILBY Post by: SwedeChildO'Mine on January 16, 2005, 06:03:16 PM Steven & Izzy of course
Title: Re: STEVE VS MATT, IZZY VS GILBY Post by: usurper on January 17, 2005, 10:59:31 AM Matt and Gilby
Title: Re: STEVE VS MATT, IZZY VS GILBY Post by: Dave_Rose on January 17, 2005, 12:07:58 PM I always preffered Matt
I with Izzy and Gilby its a tough one but if I had pick it would be Gilby Title: Re: STEVE VS MATT, IZZY VS GILBY Post by: Pryor Murphy on January 17, 2005, 12:39:27 PM well...steven didn't just LEFT, as you say it so gently... :peace:
But I have to say that Matt's the most talented one. C'mon... Izzy & Gilby? Izzy all the way... Title: Re: STEVE VS MATT, IZZY VS GILBY Post by: IzzyDutch on January 17, 2005, 12:59:14 PM Izzy and Steven
Title: Re: STEVE VS MATT, IZZY VS GILBY Post by: Gilby fan on March 18, 2005, 08:42:14 AM Gilby and matt
Title: Re: STEVE VS MATT, IZZY VS GILBY Post by: *Izzy* on March 18, 2005, 09:12:21 AM Izbo and Popcorn? :)
:smoking: Izzy? :smoking: Title: Re: STEVE VS MATT, IZZY VS GILBY Post by: Drew on March 18, 2005, 10:12:36 AM I always preferred Matt too.
And Izzy is absolutely priceless in my opinion. Title: Re: STEVE VS MATT, IZZY VS GILBY Post by: Rob on March 18, 2005, 02:42:37 PM I'd say Steve v. Matt is a toss up. I'd take Steve, but I also don't mind Matt. Izzy v. Gilby shouldn't even be an issue. Izzy is a founding member, and one of the main creative forces in the band. Gilby never wrote a damn thing for GN'R. Also he was only in the band for a couple years. Gilby Clarke was a talented guitarist, but he had nothing to do with the greatness of GN'R.
Title: Re: STEVE VS MATT, IZZY VS GILBY Post by: borntolose on March 18, 2005, 03:41:09 PM I'd say Steve v. Matt is a toss up.? I'd take Steve, but I also don't mind Matt.? Izzy v. Gilby shouldn't even be an issue.? Izzy is a founding member, and one of the main creative forces in the band.? Gilby never wrote a damn thing for GN'R.? Also he was only in the band for a couple years.? Gilby Clarke was a talented guitarist, but he had nothing to do with the greatness of GN'R. I agree! Title: Re: STEVE VS MATT, IZZY VS GILBY Post by: wadey on March 20, 2005, 02:23:06 PM popcorn Vs matt...... NO COMPETITION..
matt is a great drummer and a respected member on G N' R but no way can be compared to steven 'popcorn' adler.. the music was always faster with steven..... wonder why........? Title: Re: STEVE VS MATT, IZZY VS GILBY Post by: Gilby fan on March 20, 2005, 03:42:58 PM Gilby named the album gover for "the spaghetti incident"
gilby was the one who did a solo with slash so u see izzy doing that no and izzy was the one who left not gilby izzy is a cool person but i will have to go with gilby and matt :smoking: Title: Re: STEVE VS MATT, IZZY VS GILBY Post by: Sakib on March 20, 2005, 04:14:44 PM gilby and steve
Title: Re: STEVE VS MATT, IZZY VS GILBY Post by: borntolose on March 20, 2005, 04:59:39 PM Gilby named the album gover for "the spaghetti incident" gilby was the one who did a solo with slash so u see izzy doing that no and izzy was the one who left not gilby izzy is a cool person but i will have to go with gilby and matt :smoking: Yeah but Izzy wrote a lot of the lyrics. Title: Re: STEVE VS MATT, IZZY VS GILBY Post by: gnrfan420 on March 20, 2005, 11:03:09 PM I think matt is a much better drummer then popcorn
i'll take gilby over that fucking pussy izzy stradlin anyday Title: Re: STEVE VS MATT, IZZY VS GILBY Post by: Gilby fan on March 21, 2005, 04:53:57 PM izzy is a fucking cool writer and a guitarist
i have to admit but for me it will always be gilby and matt Title: Re: STEVE VS MATT, IZZY VS GILBY Post by: Johnny Rattlesnake on March 21, 2005, 05:08:42 PM Izzy from a song-writing stand point, Gilby from a performance stand piont.
Title: Re: STEVE VS MATT, IZZY VS GILBY Post by: Gilby fan on April 14, 2005, 03:29:19 PM yeah ii have to agree with u on that
:smoking: :beer: Title: Re: STEVE VS MATT, IZZY VS GILBY Post by: Gilby fan on April 14, 2005, 03:30:17 PM yeah i will have to agree with u on that
:smoking: :beer: Title: Re: STEVE VS MATT, IZZY VS GILBY Post by: Rob on April 19, 2005, 03:17:36 PM Gilby named the album gover for "the spaghetti incident" gilby was the one who did a solo with slash ??? What the hell does that mean? So what if Gilby named the album. Izzy was one of the main writers for the band from Appettite to the UYI's. And what solo are you talking about? I'm pretty sure Izzy's played his share of solos as well. Title: Re: STEVE VS MATT, IZZY VS GILBY Post by: slash4ever on May 07, 2005, 10:16:56 AM Theres no competition. Izzy and Steven.
Although i have always liked Matt......... Title: Re: STEVE VS MATT, IZZY VS GILBY Post by: duffsgal on May 08, 2005, 01:42:57 AM Steven and Izzy - would always take the original members over the replacements any day.
Title: Re: STEVE VS MATT, IZZY VS GILBY Post by: Koskenkorvasieni on May 11, 2005, 10:48:09 PM Izzy from a song-writing stand point, Gilby from a performance stand piont. I was just about to post the same. ;D As for Steven vs. Matt...Steven was a great drummer in his better days, but he let his drug addictions get in the way of the music. Matt is good drummer also, so i'll go with Sorum on this one. Although I would be extremely interested to hear Steven play the UYI material and see if he could pull it off :D Title: Re: STEVE VS MATT, IZZY VS GILBY Post by: usurper on May 12, 2005, 06:22:11 AM Izzy from a song-writing stand point, Gilby from a performance stand piont. I was just about to post the same.? ;D As for Steven vs. Matt...Steven was a great drummer in his better days, but he let his drug addictions get in the way of the music. Matt is good drummer also, so i'll go with Sorum on this one. Although I would be extremely interested to hear Steven play the UYI material and see if he could pull it off? :D I doubt Steven could successfully pull it off, listen to Dead Horse's drumming, Steven wont be able to pull that off, thats pure talent playing Title: Re: STEVE VS MATT, IZZY VS GILBY Post by: Fudgin_Hell on May 16, 2005, 09:58:14 AM DUDES!!!
izzy over gilby any day 8) Izzy was probilly the most important member in a way... matt sorebum jus sounds like a drum machine to me so i'd go 4 steven :smoking: Title: Re: STEVE VS MATT, IZZY VS GILBY Post by: Rob on May 16, 2005, 03:45:51 PM Yeah, Steve's drumming is so much looser. Matt is very technical and he gets a little boring at times. Steve is always switching stuff up. I prefer drummers who mix it up.
|