Here Today... Gone To Hell!

Guns N' Roses => Guns N' Roses => Topic started by: Eric on December 31, 2004, 07:19:38 AM



Title: madagascar/Green Day's Boulevard of Broken Dreams
Post by: Eric on December 31, 2004, 07:19:38 AM
 I was listening to Boulevard of Broken dreams in the car yesterday-a great song, I think-it really reminds me of Madagascar-take out Dizzy's keyboard part, it has a similar drum beat, and the guitar effects near the end remind me of Madagascar also-both are beautiful songs, even similar in theme in some ways-I think it's one of Green Day's best-wish I could hear studio version of Maddy-come on, Axl, you're killing me. Just my opinion, anyway.


Title: Re: madagascar/Green Day's Boulevard of Broken Dreams
Post by: Chuzeville on December 31, 2004, 08:22:01 AM
What strikes me most about this song is how obviously it rips off Oasis' Wonderwall.


Title: Re: madagascar/Green Day's Boulevard of Broken Dreams
Post by: Dr. Blutarsky on December 31, 2004, 10:43:23 AM
It shows Green Day can go beyond the typical 3 minute  3 chord punk song. Its cool to see when bands are talented enough to progress as artists instead of making the same album over & over.  I have a feeling VR~s next album will be Contraband 2.

As far as Madagascar is concerned, it is much more adventurous as "Boulevard."  Axl reached a little farther to create a truly unique song. I hope he doesn`t ruin it in the studio considering how much time it is taking. If it is overproduced , it could turn into crap. However, I am optomistic it will be awesome.


Title: Re: madagascar/Green Day's Boulevard of Broken Dreams
Post by: dave-gnfnr2k on December 31, 2004, 11:28:51 AM
It shows Green Day can go beyond the typical 3 minute? 3 chord punk song. Its cool to see when bands are talented enough to progress as artists instead of making the same album over & over.? I have a feeling VR~s next album will be Contraband 2.

As far as Madagascar is concerned, it is much more adventurous as "Boulevard."? Axl reached a little farther to create a truly unique song. I hope he doesn`t ruin it in the studio considering how much time it is taking. If it is overproduced , it could turn into crap. However, I am optomistic it will be awesome.

Have you listened to greendays new album? They have a ten minute song on there and its very good.


Title: Re: madagascar/Green Day's Boulevard of Broken Dreams
Post by: Saul on December 31, 2004, 12:13:51 PM
Boulvard Of Broken Dreams is right now easily one of my favs over madagascar. Maybe it's because madagascar is so old and played now or that we havent had a studio version ... but I like Boulevard much much more.

Green days new album is stellar!


Title: Re: madagascar/Green Day's Boulevard of Broken Dreams
Post by: Speedy0587 on December 31, 2004, 03:01:03 PM
Posted by: Chuzeville
Quote
Insert Quote
What strikes me most about this song is how obviously it rips off Oasis' Wonderwall.

 ::I have no idea how to do that quote box::

My friend said the same exact thing and then i noticed it too. We sang the words to Wonderwall while BOBD was playing. It was interesting.


Title: Re: madagascar/Green Day's Boulevard of Broken Dreams
Post by: Saul on December 31, 2004, 03:06:29 PM
Posted by: Chuzeville
Quote
Insert Quote
What strikes me most about this song is how obviously it rips off Oasis' Wonderwall.

 ::I have no idea how to do that quote box::

My friend said the same exact thing and then i noticed it too. We sang the words to Wonderwall while BOBD was playing. It was interesting.

Yeah , cause the tremolo effect in wonderwall is awesome! And how that heavy distortion come in during the chourus of wonderwall.  ::)


Title: Re: madagascar/Green Day's Boulevard of Broken Dreams
Post by: Speedy0587 on December 31, 2004, 04:12:56 PM
Saul, im in no way trying to bash Green Day. They are one of my favorite bands.
The verses in both songs have the same chords ( i think or variations of the same chord). Each song has something special which makes us like it. I was just saying that we were singing the words to Wonderwall to BOBD and it was just funny. :)


Title: Re: madagascar/Green Day's Boulevard of Broken Dreams
Post by: Saul on December 31, 2004, 04:58:05 PM
Saul, im in no way trying to bash Green Day. They are one of my favorite bands.
The verses in both songs have the same chords ( i think or variations of the same chord). Each song has something special which makes us like it. I was just saying that we were singing the words to Wonderwall to BOBD and it was just funny. :)

Thats no problem. I heard a remix of both songs mixed together and it sounded pretty funny.

Songs having the same chords and/or strumming patterns is not too unusual , hell GNR have ripped themselves off a couple times too.

peace bro!  :peace:


Title: Re: madagascar/Green Day's Boulevard of Broken Dreams
Post by: killingvector on December 31, 2004, 07:23:38 PM
BOBD is very good, but Madagascar gave me goosebumps the first time and every time I've heard it.


Title: Re: madagascar/Green Day's Boulevard of Broken Dreams
Post by: Billo on January 01, 2005, 05:28:56 AM
BOBDs is a GREAT song but it dosent remind me of maddy at all... :peace:  I hope they put the first vers of it from RIO3 on CD....its the best.. :beer:
Anyway..when i heard BOBDs i actually got the AIdiot CD..its the first one of theres ive got and its great....Not really PUNK...mostly roch ..and i like the 10 min songs with all the different acts..and all the changes..its cool and different.. :hihi: :beer:


Title: Re: madagascar/Green Day's Boulevard of Broken Dreams
Post by: norway on January 01, 2005, 09:23:08 AM
i really like the solopart from rio, i liked that part better when it wasn't trimmed down

but the other stuff got better, like in vma : ok: