Here Today... Gone To Hell!

Now that is confirmed that BH is out I want to say... I miss the old structure
1 singer, 2 guitarists, 1 bassist, 1 drummer and even 1 keyboradist (drop pittman)

Why does GNR need to replace BH ?
Isn't Finck a good guitar player to take lead guitar ?... if not, then why is he there ?

Well mainly axl wanted 3 players to nail the complexity of the songs live but still no I honestly would hate to think of Finck as the top gunner in GNR.  I mean c'mon no more NIGHTRAIN shred, that piss poor SCOM and NR solo and god only knows what else.

I like the three guitarist idea..its something new and dynamic

As for Finck - i have friends that play GNR solo's better than he does...why he is in the band is a good question.......

He's not good enough to be lead guitarist in GNR.

I'm the only one whothinks that Finck is a pretty good player?!? :confused:

I say fire that asshole !!! get out finck and get a real lead player !!!
and I hope is a rocker, not a strange alien from underground again (sorry, but I prefered Slash or Gilby kind of guitar player than BH)

No, i like Finck a lot!

well... yes !
I think is something obvious that only a few people consider him a good player

No, I've always dug his playing as well..

Whe I first knew of Finck join GNR I thought it was good news, I mean I knew him from NIN and liked a lot, but I have read here what fans think of him and I have heard that bootlegs where his guitar sounds shameful and I am dissapointed.

As if for example Slash never fucked up anything.
Come on we all have a bad day sometimes, i saw him performing at Pukkelpop and he stole my heart there with his performance.

Finck is really good.  He impressed me when they played here.  I think he could handle the job.

GnR were never intended to have 2 lead guitar players...


Robin was in.... Then when he quit Buckethead came in... Robin wanted back in so Axl said  "Fuck it 2 are better than 1"

They will not replace Buckethead if he is in fact gone...  2 guitarists playing lead was NEVER in the original plan.....

Without hearing more new material theres really no way for use to judge the need or usefullness of 3 guitar players. I quite like Robin, he may not be any Slash but offhand no names come to mind that i rather see replace him at the moment. I think Axl will replace Buckethead but with who we do not know. The 3 guitarist particularily on the old material were not essentially needed. Take WTTJ for example, Buckethead standed around until the solo and then played it and was done. I much more considered Robin lead guitarist over Buckethead, as someone already pointed put it doesn't seem as if Buckethead plays a single note on The Blues.

The band was perfect.  Bucket, Finck, Brain, Axl, Tommy etc.  Buckethead was the main focus besides Axl.  Just say it ain't so.  Axl and Bucket were a hell of a combo so just hope its not true.

Robin is great player  :peace:

would like to see him and fortus do it themselves.

(I've seen them live and seen 4 bootlegs....i'm dissappointed to lose the bucket but believe it's not the end.)

why does everyone think Fink is a bad guitar player?.......because he doesn't play the old GNR song's solos EXACTLY as they should be. I mean come on, your judging him on playing someone elses material, ofcourse its not gonna be as good he didn't write those old songs/solos.

But then you say "oh well there are so many people who could play the SCOM and NT solos better than fink". Well if GNR are to survive they aren't gonna do it by playing the old material, so we shouldnt judge fink on his playing on that. Jeez give the guy a break.

Me personally as a guitarist absolutely suck at playing other people's solos. But when it comes to improvising my own and writing my own........they can kick ass. I have friends who can play other people's solos note for note.......sound perfect........but when it comes to making their own their clueless. GNR don't need a lead guitarist that can play the old material PERFECTLY.........they need a guitarist that can make NEW material/riffs/solos that are just as good.

Just because you can play the SCOM solo better than fink doesn't mean your a better guitarist than him.........just remember whose in GNR and who isnt. ;)

Excuse me,  but robin finck is a great musician!  :yes: He plays with his heart ,believe me, if you dont, why dont you listen to The guitar solo in the Blues,hu?  :P

Finck rules.  Are people just not used to watching someone play with so much feeling?  Robin has more talent than anyone I know and he is one of the most exciting people to watch on stage in the Gn'R line-up.

You must be kidding :rofl:

True...

However, like Ive said before, Ive heard nothing (solos) from Robin Finck that is as good as any of the old GNR stuff and generally dont care for him as a GNR member.  I especially dont like his playing in the "Sweet Child" remake... :no:

and you're forgetting that Fortus is a hell of a lead player!

finck is definately good enough to be in the band hes really good i love the blues solo

robin rules!!!! i love robin! and his apperance is awesome! he is my only reason to cut my hair too 8starting to loose it)  :hihi:



finck all the way!

robin, richard and tommy.. they rules :D

btw, why is everyone reffering to the new members by last name?

Nope, and if you don't already know them, check out these sites:

http://www.robinfinck.com
http://www.robinfinck-birdhouse.com
http://www.robinfinck.net

if you don't like robin's playing, you might not end up liking chinese democracy. axl knew he couldn't replace slash with someone like slash. robin plays a very different kind of guitar, and that's the sound axl chose for this album. robin probably has more impact on the new album than anyone besides axl.

on topic, i don't think gnr needs 3 guitar players, but i did like the sound. it was full and impressive, and i thought paradise city was fun to watch. so i'd like to see them replace bucket, even though i think whoever it is will take a backseat (less of 2 leads, and more robin on lead and fortus and someone else also on stage). either way, i now can't imagine what we'll hear from axl (if we do) about all of this.

Well, Fortus was going to be the lead guitarist a few years ago, before Buckethead joined, but when BH did join, Axl forgot about the idea for a while, but then hired Fortus in the end, after Huge left...so I don't see why he won't be the guy to replace BH now.

I enjoyed the full wall of sound...i don't think, at this point, that anyone else should be brought in...just release the stuff and see what flies from there.